James pethokoukis, thinking about the laffer curve, aeideas june 3, 2019. Limitations of the laffer curve as a justification for tax. Nor is it really empirical, since varying tax rates while holding constant every other contributor to government revenues is an experiment that has never been done. What does this position on the laffer curve mean in terms of taxation for the u. Blinderthe ideas of economists andpolitical philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. What does this position on the laffer curve mean in terms of taxation for sweden. The laffer curve revisited by mathias trabandt and harald uhlig, nber working paper no. On the other hand, pecorino considers a twosector model, in which tax treatments differ across.
The idea, famously sketched by then usceconomics professor arthur laffer, was. Lafer curve explained that lower tax rate could encourage an additional output and it would increase income, which builds bigger tax base in an economy. Contracting for privacy precaution in the shadow of state. Tax rate cuts and tax compliance the laffer curve revisited. Debt laffer curve for south asian countries 709 the relationship between the nominal face value of the debt outstanding and the market value of the debt is related in the form of debt laffer curve. The laffer curve is named this way due to his main supporter and researcher about that theory, arthur laffer. Evidence on the highincome laffer curve from six decades of tax reform brookings papers on economic activity, 1999, no. Arthur laffer by iea current controversies paper no.
Laffer chats with republican governor of texas rick perry in 2008. This could be the tax rate on consumption, labor income, capital income or something more speci c such as the top federal tax rate on ordinary income. The laffer curve was conceptualized for modern economies by arthur laffer during a meeting in which he argued against president gerald fords tax increase. Estimates have been made of the peak of the laffer curve.
The laffer curve concept infers that a tax rate cut could lead to an increase in tax revenue, or a decrease in tax revenue, depending whether you have already passed the optimal tax rate whatever % that may be tax rate t3 might be considered optimal if the objective is to maximise total tax revenues. Evidence on the highincome laffer curve from six decades. Keynes the first part of the paper by canto, joines, and laffer, which is. Pdf the laffer curve, part 1 bruce bartlett academia. Arthur laffer, american economist who propounded the idea that lowering tax rates could result in higher revenues. The laffer curve describes how changes in tax rates affect government revenues in two ways.
The laffer curve is a theory that states lower tax rates boost economic growth. This is because at 100%, there is no incentive for the individual to earn any money, as there will be none they can take home. It is a theoretical representation of the relationship between gov. A copy of the license is included in the section entitled gnu free documentation license. The main use to which the economics profession has put the laffer curve at least if you judge by a representative sample of principles and intermediate textbooks is to choose that tax rate which maximizes governmental revenues. The market value of the debt of a country is determined by the secondary market price of the debt as postulated by claessens 1990 and cohen 1989. Evidences from growth laffer curve for sri lanka s. Diagram of the laffer curve while there can be no objection among economists to the theoretical existence of the laffer curve, there have been many visceral objections that it exists in practice. Limitations of the laffer curve as ajustification for tax cuts david henderson professor laffer s paper leads me to ask four questions, which i. Laffer drew the famous laffer curve, which showed that, starting from a zero tax rate, increases in tax rates will increase the governments tax revenue but that, at some point, when the rates become high enough, further increases in tax rates will decrease revenue. A laffer curve of cyber crime the foregoing analysis of private precautions takes as given particular levels of public precaution taking and government enforcement efforts including expected punishments. Thats the thing that economist arthur laffer, in the company of his sidekick jude wanniski, drew on a napkin showing that tax cuts pay for themselves. The laffer curve is the most famous, nonempirical economic concept of the last fifty years.
The laffer curve is not derived from some other curve by any type of math at all. The laffer curve shows the relationship between tax revenue collected by the government and tax rates paid by citizens. The laffer curve by itself doesnt say whether a tax cut will raise or lower revenues. Laffer curve theory to the modern global digital economy. It underpins supplyside economics, reaganomics, and the tea partys economic policies.
Laffer curve considering the range of real and financial responses to corporate taxes, it is likely that cutting the high u. Thus, the public policy variable under consideration is a tax rate on some speci ed component of income or expenditure. Permission is granted to copy, distribute andor modify this document under the terms of the gnu free documentation license, version 1. Despite the laffer curve s 1980s flop, republicans have steadfastly refused to give up on the theory. Government enforcement efforts, of course, can vary, and affect private precautiontaking in. Papp and elod takats authorized for distribution by marianne schulzeghattas january 2008 abstract this working paper should not be reported as representing the views of the imf. Figure 1 below represents a graphical depiction of a laffer curve. Large tax laffer curve the laffer curve depicts the relationship between the size of a tax and the amount of tax revenue arthur laffer, creator of the laffer curve, suggested that the usa is already on the downwardslope of the curve. A personal income taxbased analysis for turkey this version. The laffer curve said to be based on the supply side economics. The views expressed in this working paper are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent. The phillips curve shows tradeoff between inflation and unemployment.
Evidence on the highincome laffer curve from six decades of tax reform in the 1980s, federal income tax policy took center stage in the political arena. Thats right tax cuts pay for themselves, by so increasing economic activity that the total revenue take is higher after the tax cut than before. Revenue responses to a tax rate change will depend upon the tax system in place, the time period being figure 1. This implies that larger taxes would have multiple negative effects. The sketch of laffer curve was drawn by arther laffer at a dinner with his friends on his napkin that reduction in taxes will increase tax revenues. The laffer curve is a theory developed by supplyside economist arthur laffer to show the relationship between tax rates and the amount of tax revenue collected by governments.
Big economic ideas from art laffer and steve forbes, by. Keynes the first part of the paper by canto, joines, and laffer. The story of how the laffer curve got its name begins with a 1978 article by jude wanniski in the public interest entitled, taxes, revenues, and the laffer curve. In its most general form, the laffer curve depicts the relationship between tax rates and the revenue the government receivesthat is, a single tax rate exists that maximizes the amount of revenue the government obtains from taxation. Jayasooriya1 chartered economist economic policy, innvoation4development consultants, sri lanka abstract. The shape of the curve is a function of taxable income elasticity. The representation tries to prove that there is an optimal point when maximizing revenues by changing the income tax, and not always the increase in. Taxable capacity with diagram economics discussion.
The laffer curve revisited 1 by mathias trabandt 2 and harald uhlig 3 1 a number of people and seminar participants provided us with excellent comments, for which we are grateful, and a complete list would be rather long. Specifically, it mimics the curve found in figure 2 of that paper. Public economic policies are vital for the provision of efficient public services, in which optimal taxation system to promote economic growth in sri lanka. In economics, the laffer curve illustrates a theoretical relationship between rates of taxation and the resulting levels of the governments tax revenue. He showed the relationship between taxes and revenue in the laffer curve. Pdf on the use and misuse of the laffer curve walter. Tax cuts were supposed to encourage people to work, which would have increased the labor supplied.
The tax rates depicted on a laffer curve range from 0% to 100%. The shape of the curve is a function of taxable income elasticity i. A little laffer curve reality should guide republican tax. What happens to inflation and unemployment when ad increase. Goals of these lectures 1 understand the core optimal income tax model. This short article underlines the efficiency considerations reflected by a laffer curve.
897 1580 572 252 277 641 1420 955 1495 805 1594 210 1245 721 616 600 1586 1420 1520 192 1230 260 338 1334 344 238 984 1256 497 183 217 571 1335 208